Tony Stewart’s Hidden Hollow Ranch, a sprawling 415-acre retreat outside Columbus, Indiana, is back on the luxury real estate market for $18.9 million, offering a rare combination of private wilderness, resort-style amenities and a nearly 20,000-square-foot custom lodge.
The property was created by Stewart over many years after he purchased the land in 2004. The three-time NASCAR Cup Series champion eventually developed the estate into a highly personalized retreat, completing the main residence in 2011. Today, Hidden Hollow Ranch encompasses a 19,714-square-foot lodge, a nine-acre stocked lake, guest accommodations, a large workshop, extensive recreational facilities and a licensed hunting preserve.
The current offering represents a significant repositioning from the property’s earlier appearances on the market. Stewart first listed Hidden Hollow Ranch for $30 million in 2022, when it was described as one of the most expensive residential listings ever offered in Indiana. The ranch returned to the market in 2024 at $22.5 million before being repositioned again at the current $18.9 million asking price.
For California Luxury Houses, however, the most interesting part of Hidden Hollow Ranch is not simply its price or celebrity ownership. It is the way Stewart transformed a large tract of Indiana countryside into a deeply personal compound designed around hunting, fishing, motorsports, entertaining and spending time with family and friends.
Tony Stewart Built Hidden Hollow Ranch as His Private Escape
Stewart began assembling the property in 2004, eventually turning the land near his hometown of Columbus into what he has previously described as his dream home. The completed lodge was built in 2011 and uses lodgepole pine sourced from the Northern Rockies, while other materials were brought in from across the country, including Texas stone, Indiana bedrock and custom lighting from Utah and Alaska.
The result is deliberately different from the polished contemporary estates often associated with celebrity real estate.
Hidden Hollow Ranch embraces the language of an enormous wilderness lodge, but at a scale that borders on theatrical. Massive timber beams, stone fireplaces, wildlife displays and water features give the interior the atmosphere of a private sporting club.
Stewart previously explained the thinking behind the property in unusually personal terms.
“This is truly my dream home,” Stewart said when the ranch was first listed for sale. He described it as a place where he could escape and relax with family and friends, adding that the land offered opportunities for hunting, fishing, off-roading or simply sitting on the porch under the stars.
That philosophy remains visible throughout the property.
The current listing is represented by Carrie Holle of the Carrie Holle Group, affiliated with Compass. The official Hidden Hollow Ranch marketing site describes the property as a 19,713-square-foot estate with six bedrooms, eight full bathrooms and three half-baths, while emphasizing its nine-acre lake, wildlife preserve and extensive recreational amenities.
Holle has also spoken about the property in remarkably enthusiastic terms.
“The very first time I visited Hidden Hollow Ranch, I was absolutely floored,” Holle said in an interview about the estate.
Her reaction becomes easier to understand once the main house comes into view.
A Lodge-Style Residence With a Waterfall and 8,700-Gallon Aquarium
Entry to Hidden Hollow Ranch begins behind wood-and-iron gates set between substantial stone pillars. From there, a private drive passes through mature trees before arriving at the lodge.
The exterior establishes the property’s rustic vocabulary immediately. Lodgepole pine from the Northern Rockies forms much of the structure, while stonework, heavy timber beams and carved doors give the residence the character of an elaborate Western lodge rather than a conventional Indiana mansion.
Inside, the arrival sequence is even more dramatic.
A wooden bridge crosses a flowing trout and koi stream before opening into the great room, where enormous log trusses rise above the living space. At the center is one of the property’s defining features: an 8,700-gallon freshwater aquarium incorporated into a two-story waterfall installation.
The water feature is surrounded by natural stone, branches and wildlife displays, while leather seating and timber furnishings reinforce the hunting-lodge aesthetic.
The aquarium is stocked with freshwater species, while the entry stream and waterfall create the unusual sensation that a piece of the surrounding landscape has been brought indoors.
Holle has previously singled out this arrival experience as one of the property’s most memorable elements.
“It’s probably the most exceptional property I’ve ever been in. You walk in and immediately you hear the waterfall. Then you cross over a stream that he has stocked with giant koi,” she told You Are Current.
The great room leads into a formal dining area and a substantial kitchen. The kitchen includes dark stone counters, extensive wood cabinetry, a large range and a built-in hibachi grill beneath a commercial-grade exhaust system. A separate butler’s pantry provides additional refrigeration, storage and preparation space.
The home’s entertainment spaces become even more ambitious downstairs.
A dedicated lower level includes a two-lane bowling alley, arcade and game area, poker tables, billiards, a golf simulator and a lighted onyx bar. Racing memorabilia is displayed throughout the space, including helmets and a full race car mounted as a centerpiece.
For a buyer with an interest in motorsports, the collection of recreational spaces makes the residence particularly personal. The house does not merely accommodate entertainment; it appears to have been designed around it.
Six Bedrooms, a Private Guesthouse and 415 Acres of Wilderness
The primary suite continues the lodge aesthetic, with exposed logs, timber beams and a stone fireplace positioned opposite the bed. A private office, wet bar and laundry area connect to the suite, while the bathroom features dual vanities, a glass-enclosed shower and a soaking tub overlooking the surrounding greenery.
Several additional bedrooms occupy the main residence, each maintaining the timber-heavy architectural vocabulary while offering different configurations and access to balconies or views of the grounds.
Beyond the main lodge, the property includes a guesthouse and a large workshop. Earlier listing materials described the guesthouse as approximately 3,500 square feet, providing additional accommodation for visitors or extended stays.
But the buildings account for only a small part of what makes Hidden Hollow Ranch unusual.
The property covers 415 acres of wooded land, including a nine-acre stocked lake with trophy bass and a dock. The surrounding forest has been maintained as a licensed hunting preserve, with the current marketing materials describing populations of approximately 300 deer, 15 elk and wild turkey.
The acreage creates a degree of privacy that is increasingly difficult to find in celebrity-owned real estate.
There are no neighboring luxury estates crowding the boundaries or urban amenities competing with the landscape. Instead, the property is structured around the land itself, with the lodge serving as a central gathering point for outdoor activities.
The official property website calls Hidden Hollow Ranch “a true playground for adults,” a description that captures the unusual balance between wilderness retreat and private entertainment complex.
For Holle, the combination of natural materials and elaborate amenities is part of what separates the ranch from conventional luxury properties.
“Hidden Hollow Ranch is an extraordinary legacy ranch property that spans over 400 pristine acres, combining the natural beauty of the terrain with luxurious amenities,” Holle said when the property returned to the market in 2024. She also highlighted the lodgepole pine, white oak, red hardwood, Texas stone and Indiana bedrock used throughout the estate.
A Private Ranch Near Columbus With Access to Indianapolis
Although Hidden Hollow Ranch feels deliberately remote, its location near Columbus gives residents access to a surprisingly sophisticated small-city environment.
Columbus is internationally recognized for its architecture and public art, an unusual distinction for a community of roughly 50,000 residents. The city is home to more than 80 notable buildings and public-art installations and is frequently promoted as an architectural destination. It is located roughly 45 minutes south of Indianapolis, providing a connection to the larger metropolitan area without requiring residents to live in an urban setting.
Downtown Columbus offers independent shops, restaurants, cafés, galleries and cultural attractions, while the city also has a strong outdoor-recreation component. The local tourism organization highlights walking trails, parks, gardens and other outdoor destinations throughout the community.
For shopping, residents can turn to downtown boutiques and specialty stores, while the Indiana Premium Outlets and Exit 76 Antique Mall are located near I-65. The premium outlet center has approximately 85 stores, adding a more conventional retail option to the area’s collection of independent shops and antique destinations.
Dining options range from local restaurants and cafés in downtown Columbus to establishments near the Columbus Municipal Airport. The city’s tourism guides highlight restaurants such as The Garage Pub & Grill, 450 North Brewing Company and Blackerby’s Hangar 5, among others.
The regional connection is particularly useful for a property of this scale. Columbus sits roughly an hour from Indianapolis, Louisville and Cincinnati, while Indianapolis International Airport provides access to national and international travel.
That accessibility helps explain how Stewart could maintain a sprawling private retreat without being completely removed from a major metropolitan center.
From a $30 Million Record-Setting Listing to $18.9 Million
Hidden Hollow Ranch’s market history is almost as remarkable as the property itself.
When Stewart first listed the estate in March 2022, the asking price was $30 million. At the time, the property was described as the most expensive home listing in Indiana, and the price represented a potential record for the state.
The timing also provided insight into why Stewart was ready to part with the ranch.
According to reporting at the time, Holle told The Wall Street Journal that Stewart traveled extensively and was no longer able to spend enough time at the property.
That explanation fits the property’s history. Stewart spent years assembling and developing Hidden Hollow Ranch, then lived there for more than a decade. It was not an investment property assembled purely for resale; it was designed around his personal interests and lifestyle.
The ranch later returned to the market in April 2024 at $22.5 million. At that stage, the listing emphasized the same combination of 415 acres, the 19,714-square-foot lodge, nine-acre lake and extensive indoor entertainment amenities.
The current $18.9 million asking price represents another substantial repositioning.
At that figure, a buyer is acquiring not only the residence but an enormous recreational compound with a private lake, hunting preserve, guest accommodations and facilities that would be extraordinarily difficult to replicate from scratch.
For California Luxury Houses, that distinction is important. Hidden Hollow Ranch is not competing directly with conventional celebrity mansions in Los Angeles or Miami. Its appeal lies in scarcity: very few luxury properties combine this amount of acreage, a custom-built lodge of this scale and such a concentrated collection of private recreational amenities.
The ranch therefore occupies its own category of luxury real estate.
The Legacy of Tony Stewart’s Hidden Hollow Ranch
There is something unusually personal about Hidden Hollow Ranch.
Stewart’s racing career took him around the world, but the property remained rooted in Columbus, the Indiana city where he grew up. Rather than build a sleek contemporary mansion disconnected from the landscape, he created a home that reflects his interests in racing, hunting, fishing, outdoor recreation and entertaining.
That personality is visible everywhere.
A stream runs through the entryway. A waterfall rises beside a giant aquarium. A bowling alley sits downstairs. Racing memorabilia shares space with poker tables and billiards. Outside, a nine-acre lake anchors hundreds of acres of forest populated by wildlife.
And despite all of that, the property retains the atmosphere of a retreat.
That may be the most compelling feature for its next owner.
Hidden Hollow Ranch does not attempt to imitate an urban luxury resort. It offers something more difficult to find: the freedom to create an entire private world within 415 acres of Indiana countryside.
At $18.9 million, Tony Stewart’s Hidden Hollow Ranch is now looking for a buyer willing to embrace that world. For someone seeking privacy, recreation and an unusually personalized form of luxury, the estate offers an experience that few traditional mansions could match.
The house may have been built for a NASCAR champion, but its next chapter will belong to someone who sees the same value Stewart once did in having a place where the day can be spent fishing on a private lake, competing in a bowling alley, practicing on a golf simulator—or simply sitting outside and watching the stars.