A Mansion Steeped in Infamy and Grandeur

In a neighborhood known for exclusivity and elegance, one Staten Island estate stands apart—not just for its size or luxury, but for its place in American mob history. The Gambino Crime Family’s Former New York Estate, once the home of notorious boss Paul “Big Paul” Castellano, has officially returned to the market with an asking price of $18 million.

Located in the prestigious enclave of Todt Hill, this opulent mansion was inspired by the architecture of the White House and has become a local landmark for its scale, symmetry, and storied past. Castellano lived in this residence until his assassination in 1985—a pivotal moment that marked the rise of John Gotti and a reshuffling of the American mafia’s power structure.

White House-Inspired Design Meets Italian Opulence

Spanning an extraordinary 33,000 square feet, the estate is anything but subtle. The property greets visitors with a grand circular driveway, central fountain, and a façade framed by Romanesque columns and stone balustrades. Built in 1980, the home was designed to impress, intimidate, and entertain—a trifecta that defined Castellano’s reign over the Gambino empire.

Inside, eight lavish bedroom suites and 17 bathrooms cater to both comfort and status. Marble flooring, mirrored ceilings, gold-trimmed moldings, and floor-to-ceiling windows point to a bygone era of maximalism. However, modern upgrades keep the home current, including advanced security systems and state-of-the-art climate controls.

Amenities Tailored for Power and Privacy

The Gambino Crime Family’s Former New York Estate isn’t just a relic of the past; it’s a fully equipped luxury residence. Amenities include:

  • A private 13-car garage showroom with polished flooring and display lighting
  • Indoor and outdoor Olympic-sized pools, ideal for entertaining or relaxation
  • A full-service beauty salon, gym with sauna, and spa room
  • A 12-seat home theater and mahogany wine cellar
  • Solarium, billiards room, and wraparound terraces with panoramic views of the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge

The 1.75-acre lot offers manicured gardens, gated access, and enough space to ensure full privacy—an essential asset, both in the mafia days and today.

Breaking Price Records in Staten Island

Currently listed by Melsa Skrapalliu of RJM Realty Empire Inc., this is the most expensive property ever listed in Staten Island. If sold at asking price, it would set a borough record, far surpassing the previous high of $4.6 million.

Despite its past, the mansion has seen serious interest from collectors of iconic properties, real estate investors, and ultra-high-net-worth individuals who value exclusivity. The estate was last sold in 2000 for $3.1 million and has since undergone multimillion-dollar renovations to bring its infrastructure and finishes to modern standards.

A Living Monument to New York’s Underworld

While luxury homes often come with stories, few rival the lore behind The Gambino Crime Family’s Former New York Estate. This is not just a house; it’s a cultural artifact, a symbol of power, wealth, and the dark glamour of America’s organized crime history.

For buyers with a penchant for legendary real estate and a taste for architectural drama, this Todt Hill estate offers a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.

Conclusion: Where Luxury Meets Legacy

From its notorious roots to its unmatched amenities, The Gambino Crime Family’s Former New York Estate merges high-end living with historical intrigue. The $18 million listing invites not just a new owner, but a new chapter in the story of one of New York’s most talked-about properties. For those seeking a home with timeless impact—and timeless headlines—this is the crown jewel of Staten Island.