Just three years after purchasing what he once described as “paradise,” actor and comedian Pete Davidson is parting ways with his beloved North Salem retreat in Westchester County, New York. The former Saturday Night Live star has listed the property for $2.275 million as he prepares to spend more time closer to his growing family in Staten Island.
Nestled on more than six private acres at 258 Hardscrabble Road, the secluded estate offers a rare combination of rustic character, modern comforts, and the tranquility that first drew Davidson away from New York City. The comedian acquired the property in 2023 for approximately $1.95 million, shortly after departing SNL and during the period when he was developing and starring in the Peacock comedy series Bupkis.
According to sources familiar with the listing, Davidson has extensively personalized the property while preserving the charm of the original residence, which dates back to the 1930s.
“Pete was very intentional about every improvement he made,” a representative familiar with the property told californialuxuryhouses. “He wanted the home to feel authentic and comfortable rather than overly polished. The goal was to enhance its character, not erase its history.”
A Country Retreat Designed for Privacy and Comfort
Approached through an elaborate wrought-iron gate and a long private drive, the estate feels worlds away from the bustle of Manhattan despite being within reach of New York City.
The residence sits amid rolling lawns, mature trees, and a picturesque pond that enhances the property’s serene atmosphere. Privacy is one of the home’s defining features, with neighboring residences positioned far enough away to create an exceptionally secluded environment.
Inside, exposed beams, warm finishes, and oversized gathering spaces create an inviting country-house aesthetic. The great room serves as the heart of the home, anchored by a dramatic stone fireplace that rises nearly to the ceiling and establishes a cozy focal point throughout the colder months.
Floor-to-ceiling windows and sliding glass doors allow natural light to flood the interiors while connecting living spaces to the surrounding landscape.
“The setting is what buyers immediately respond to,” the listing representative told californialuxuryhouses. “You can spend an entire weekend here and forget that one of the world’s largest metropolitan areas is only a short drive away.”
Personalized Features Reflect Davidson’s Lifestyle
The property has become more than simply a residence for Davidson. It has served as a creative hub, production venue, and personal sanctuary during a transformative chapter in his life.
Several commercials were filmed at the estate, including promotional work for Crocs. Davidson also used the home’s garage as a production space for his podcast projects, while various rooms became familiar backdrops for friends and collaborators visiting the property.
Among the home’s most distinctive features is a dedicated gaming and media outbuilding, offering a separate entertainment retreat from the main residence. The property also includes a screened porch overlooking the grounds, a lap pool discreetly integrated into the home, and the oversized fish tank that Davidson famously joked about during an appearance on Late Night with Seth Meyers.
The kitchen combines practicality with understated elegance, featuring custom cabinetry and a casual dining island designed for everyday living rather than formal entertaining.
“Many celebrity homes prioritize spectacle,” a local luxury real estate professional told californialuxuryhouses. “This property is different because it feels genuinely livable. It balances privacy, comfort, and personality in a way that resonates with today’s buyers.”
Family Motivated the Move
While Davidson has often spoken affectionately about the home and the North Salem community, family considerations ultimately influenced his decision to sell.
The actor recently welcomed his daughter, Scottie Rose Hewitt Davidson, with actress and model Elsie Hewitt. With relatives concentrated in Staten Island and neighboring New Jersey, the extended commute from northern Westchester has become increasingly impractical.
For Davidson, who was raised on Staten Island, proximity to family remains a major priority as he enters a new stage of life.
The comedian has frequently praised North Salem’s laid-back atmosphere and strong sense of community. Local favorites such as Harvest Moon Farm & Orchard provide seasonal activities, cafés, and family-friendly events, while nearby towns throughout northern Westchester offer boutique shopping, equestrian facilities, golf clubs, and acclaimed dining destinations.
Transportation access also remains a significant draw for affluent buyers. Residents enjoy convenient connections to Interstate 684, Metro-North rail service, Westchester County Airport, and the greater New York metropolitan area.
A Desirable Corner of Westchester County Real Estate
North Salem Real Estate continues to attract executives, entertainers, and high-net-worth buyers seeking acreage, privacy, and a slower pace of life without sacrificing access to New York City.
The area’s limited inventory and strict zoning regulations have helped preserve its rural character, making estates of this caliber increasingly difficult to acquire.
As californialuxuryhouses reached out for additional comment regarding future plans for the property, representatives declined to discuss potential buyers or ongoing negotiations. However, market observers suggest the combination of celebrity ownership, extensive privacy, and proximity to Manhattan could generate significant interest among luxury home seekers.
For Davidson, the decision appears deeply personal rather than financial. Though the property delivered the peace and solitude he once sought, family now takes precedence over distance.
And while he may be leaving North Salem behind, the retreat he transformed into a private sanctuary remains one of Westchester County’s most distinctive celebrity-owned residences currently available on the market.