Pete Davidson’s real estate story has included Manhattan penthouses, waterfront condominiums and high-profile relationships, but one of his most revealing homes is considerably more personal: the $1.3 million Staten Island residence he purchased with his mother in 2016.
Located in the Annadale section of Staten Island, the four-bedroom, four-bathroom property became more than a luxury family house. For Davidson, it was a connection to the borough where he grew up and a place where he could retreat from the intense public attention that followed his rise on Saturday Night Live.
Property records and real estate reports identify the residence at 473 Holdridge Avenue. The home was built in 1985 and sits on a roughly 9,879-square-foot lot. The original 2016 transaction was recorded at $1.29 million, closely matching the widely reported $1.3 million purchase price.
For CaliforniaLuxuryHouses readers accustomed to stories about sprawling Beverly Hills estates and celebrity compounds, Davidson’s Staten Island home offers a different kind of luxury story—one rooted less in spectacle and more in family, privacy and familiarity.
A $1.3 Million Staten Island Home With a Family Story
Davidson and his mother, Amy Waters Davidson, purchased the Staten Island property in 2016, according to multiple real estate reports. The residence was reportedly acquired as a family home, with Davidson later using a substantial basement area as his own private living space.
The arrangement became part of Davidson’s public persona. During a 2019 appearance on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon, he explained that he and his mother had bought the house together, adding that he had a basement that functioned almost like a separate apartment. He joked about turning the space into his own retreat and initially considered calling it the “Man Cave.”
The basement was not simply a storage level. Real estate coverage described it as a substantial secondary living area, helping Davidson maintain a degree of independence while remaining under the same roof as his mother. In a 2019 interview, the comedian explained the unusual setup with characteristic humor, saying, “We bought a house together, but nobody believes that.”
That detail helps explain why the property became so closely associated with Davidson. At a time when his career was accelerating and his personal life was attracting international headlines, the Staten Island house provided an unusually ordinary point of reference.
The residence was also tied to his sister, Casey Davidson, who has been associated with the property in later public reporting. More recent coverage has indicated that Davidson still has a home base in Staten Island, although the exact occupancy of the Holdridge Avenue property is not entirely clear from public sources.
Inside the 1985-Built Annadale Residence
Public property records identify 473 Holdridge Avenue as a two-story property built in 1985. Real estate databases differ in how they classify the residence and report its square footage, but the original listing described approximately 3,760 square feet across the first and second floors, with more than 5,000 square feet including the basement.
The original marketing description emphasized a custom-built character rather than the cookie-cutter finishes associated with many suburban homes. A custom kitchen, high ceilings, four full bathrooms and a private primary wing were among the features highlighted when the property was sold in 2016.
The exterior is particularly distinctive. The residence features an all-brick façade, a formal center-hall entrance and a two-car garage. A blue-stone patio extends toward a professionally landscaped yard, creating a private outdoor area that contrasts with the urban density for which New York City is generally known.
Inside, the home combines traditional detailing with the larger proportions of a custom suburban residence. A sweeping staircase, hardwood floors, formal living spaces and a prominent brick fireplace give the interiors a more established character than the minimalist glass-and-steel aesthetic often associated with celebrity real estate.
The kitchen was another major selling point. Contemporary appliances and upgraded cabinetry were incorporated into a space designed for everyday family use rather than purely for show. That distinction is important to understanding the property: despite its $1.3 million price tag and celebrity connection, it was fundamentally a family residence.
Davidson’s basement apartment added another layer of privacy. Reports described the lower level as including a bedroom, bathroom, living space and room for entertainment, effectively allowing the comedian to create a separate environment beneath his mother’s main living area.
From Staten Island Roots to a Different Chapter
The timing of Davidson’s move into the Holdridge Avenue home made the property particularly meaningful.
The comedian was raised on Staten Island and became nationally known after joining the cast of Saturday Night Live in 2014. His connection to the borough later became central to The King of Staten Island, the 2020 film inspired in part by his own childhood and experiences.
His relationship with his mother also has deep personal significance. Davidson’s father, New York City firefighter Scott Davidson, died during the September 11 attacks when Pete was seven years old. His mother raised Pete and his younger sister on Staten Island, and the comedian has repeatedly spoken publicly about the impact of losing his father.
That history gives the family home a significance that a simple property listing cannot capture.
By 2021, Davidson had moved into a separate Staten Island condominium, paying approximately $1.2 million for the waterfront residence. Architectural Digest reported that he had been living in his mother’s basement before moving into the condominium, marking a new stage of independence while allowing him to remain close to his family and hometown.
The distinction between the two properties is important. Davidson’s later condominium was his own luxury purchase, while the Holdridge Avenue residence was fundamentally a family home purchased with his mother.
In February 2022, Davidson said he planned to leave Staten Island for Brooklyn, explaining that commuting across the bridge had become inconvenient.
His real estate trajectory has continued to evolve since then. He later acquired a property in North Salem, Westchester County, in 2023, while his Staten Island condominium ultimately faced a lengthy resale process. In 2026, reports said the condominium had been placed under contract after substantial price reductions, highlighting the difference between celebrity appeal and actual buyer demand in the luxury condominium market.
The Holdridge Avenue house, however, occupies a different place in the story.
It was never primarily about celebrity status.
It was about where Davidson came from.
A Staten Island Home That Reflects a Different Kind of Luxury
The Annadale location provides a very different residential experience from Manhattan. The neighborhood is predominantly residential, with larger lots, detached homes and a suburban atmosphere while remaining within New York City.
Public property data describes 473 Holdridge Avenue as being in Annadale, with the property positioned in a relatively car-dependent section of Staten Island. Property records also place it within Community District 3 and New York City’s School District 31.
For residents, Staten Island’s appeal lies partly in that balance: the borough offers more space and a quieter residential environment than many other parts of New York City while retaining access to the wider metropolitan area.
The trade-off is transportation. Unlike Manhattan, where residents can often rely heavily on subway and walking networks, southern Staten Island is considerably more automobile-oriented. The area nonetheless benefits from Staten Island’s road network and connections toward Brooklyn and the rest of New York City.
That combination helps explain the character of properties such as the Holdridge Avenue residence. A nearly quarter-acre lot, private yard, garage and substantial interior space are difficult to replicate in many of New York City’s more densely developed neighborhoods. Public records place the lot at approximately 9,879 square feet.
For CaliforniaLuxuryHouses, the property is interesting precisely because it illustrates another side of celebrity real estate.
Luxury is not always defined by a $20 million asking price, a resort-style pool or a panoramic ocean view. Sometimes it is simply the ability to have space, privacy and family nearby while living in the community that shaped you.
Pete Davidson’s $1.3 million Staten Island home became a reflection of that idea.
The comedian eventually moved beyond the basement and into increasingly sophisticated residences, but the Holdridge Avenue property remains connected to a particularly grounded period of his life—one in which an internationally recognized entertainer could still retreat to the borough he called home.
And that may be what makes the house more compelling than its celebrity association alone.
It is not merely a former home linked to Pete Davidson.
It is part of the story of how a Staten Island kid navigated fame without entirely leaving Staten Island behind.