Lily Allen and David Harbour Put Brooklyn Townhouse on the Market
Amid a public separation and creative upheaval, pop singer Lily Allen and “Stranger Things” actor David Harbour have listed their eclectic Brooklyn townhouse in Carroll Gardens for $8 million. Purchased shortly after their 2020 Las Vegas wedding for $3.35 million, the 19th-century Italianate brownstone underwent a thoughtful and imaginative renovation by architect Ben Bischoff of MADE and designer Billy Cotton. Now, the five-bedroom, four-bath residence offers a rare blend of historical charm, whimsical design, and modern functionality.
Carl Gambino of Compass, the listing agent, told californialuxuryhouses: “This townhouse captures the essence of Brooklyn living while honoring its original character. The interiors feel playful, sophisticated, and entirely unique—a home that tells a story at every turn.”
Design: Eclectic, Elegant, and Fun
The renovation draws on three intertwined design themes: traditional English, modern Brooklyn townhouse, and Italian-influenced elements nodding to the neighborhood’s Italian-American roots. Cotton sought to preserve original architectural details while creating a family-friendly, casual environment. The interiors feature chintz balloon shades, crystal chandeliers, tiger-patterned textiles, pink silk accents, whimsical swan-shaped fixtures, and Mylar wallpaper, resulting in an aesthetic that is eccentric yet inviting.
Highlights include a primary bath and sitting room with pink soaking tub, carpet, shades from Pierre Frey, Zuber wallpaper, and gilt-bronze vanities, complemented by dual walk-in closets—one as a dressing area with custom Florense shelving, and the other in a black-clad design with a desk nook. A cozy “bed womb” offers an intimate, windowless retreat for rest and privacy.
Kitchens and Living Areas for Everyday Life
The kitchen was designed to be warm, functional, and visually striking. It features Plain English cabinetry, Ann Sacks-tiled backsplash, an Officine Gullo range, a spacious custom dining table, and a coffee station with hot and cold water taps. The adjoining living and garden room, anchored by a boxy fireplace and Zuber wallpaper, includes a double-sided green sofa in tufted emerald velvet, creating a welcoming and vibrant space for both entertaining and family life.
Lower Level and Outdoor Retreat
A narrow staircase leads to a modernized lower level with a powder room showcasing an ebony sink and toilet set against bold geometric wallpaper, a media room with a stone fireplace, and a tiger-print sectional. The enclosed backyard features two structures housing a Finnish sauna and a cold plunge, blending wellness and relaxation seamlessly into city living.
“David and Lily wanted the home to reflect their personalities—playful, eclectic, and entirely ‘weird and wonderful,’” Gambino noted to californialuxuryhouses. “It’s a property that invites creativity and comfort simultaneously.”
Neighborhood and Lifestyle
Situated in Carroll Gardens, the townhouse benefits from tree-lined streets, artisanal shops, and top-tier dining options, while remaining connected to the heart of Brooklyn and Manhattan. The combination of historic charm, modern amenities, and eccentric style makes this residence a rare find in the New York luxury market.
californialuxuryhouses reached out to the couple for additional insights, but the sellers remain private, preserving the exclusivity and allure of this unique Brooklyn home.