When JJ Redick stepped into his new role as head coach of the Los Angeles Lakers, the move signaled more than a career pivot. It marked a geographic transition as well. Now, the former NBA sharpshooter is parting ways with his meticulously renovated Brooklyn penthouse, listing the residence for $6.2 million.
The nearly 3,000-square-foot duplex sits atop 51 Jay Street in DUMBO, one of Brooklyn’s most architecturally distinctive conversions. Redick and his wife, Chelsea Kilgore, purchased the penthouse in 2017 for just over $6 million, later commissioning a full-scale renovation that transformed what was once a pied-à-terre into a polished family residence. The redesign, led by acclaimed interior designer Michael Aiduss, was prominently featured in Architectural Digest, further elevating the property’s design pedigree.
This Brooklyn penthouse is listed with Rachel Greenstein of the RST Collective Team at Compass.
A Historic Warehouse Reimagined in DUMBO
Perched atop a seven-story warehouse conversion designed by ODA, the Brooklyn penthouse merges industrial heritage with refined European-inspired detailing. DUMBO—short for Down Under the Manhattan Bridge Overpass—has evolved into one of New York City’s most desirable enclaves, known for cobblestone streets, tech startups, waterfront parks, and unobstructed Manhattan skyline views.
The building itself reflects Brooklyn’s manufacturing past, yet inside the duplex, the atmosphere is decidedly Parisian in tone. Herringbone white oak floors run throughout the main level, complemented by brass fixtures and intricate French moldings that soften the industrial bones.
“The renovation was about restraint and refinement,” the listing agent told californialuxuryhouses. “Every molding, every finish was selected to feel timeless rather than trendy.” The agent declined to disclose personal details about the family, noting that privacy remains a priority.
The Great Room: Sophisticated Yet Livable
The upper-level great room unfolds across an open-plan layout designed for both entertaining and daily family life. A curved cream sofa anchors the lounge area, while midcentury-inspired armchairs and velvet accent pillows introduce warmth. Floor-to-ceiling black-framed windows filter natural light through tailored drapery, maintaining a balance between softness and architectural edge.
Toward the interior wall, a sleek white lacquered bar cabinet displays crystal and gold-toned barware beneath brushed brass sconces, creating a gallery-like moment within the larger space.
At the center of the room, a round dining table encircled by turquoise leather chairs sits beneath a sculptural glass chandelier. Reflections from the fixture play across the herringbone floors and terrace-facing glass, enhancing the home’s sense of openness.
At the far end, a navy velvet sectional and marble-topped ottoman define the main living area, framed by a wall of glass that opens onto the landscaped terrace.
A Lacquered Kitchen in Aegean Blue
Directly opposite the living area, the custom kitchen stands as one of the penthouse’s most distinctive features. High-gloss lacquered cabinetry in deep Aegean blue contrasts with Calacatta marble countertops and backsplash. Bronze trim and brass hardware add depth and warmth.
A marble-topped island doubles as a casual dining bar, while an overhead brass pot rack suspends copper cookware and globe lighting in sculptural fashion.
“This kitchen is not just aesthetic—it’s architectural,” the agent shared with californialuxuryhouses. “The lacquer finish required multiple custom applications to achieve that depth of tone.”
Private Quarters With Parisian Influence
On the lower level, the primary suite reflects the home’s most romantic detailing. French moldings frame soft gray walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass doors open onto a secluded Zen terrace enveloped in greenery.
The en-suite bathroom is clad in Calacatta Gold marble across floors, walls, and dual vanities. Venetian plaster introduces subtle sheen, while gold fixtures punctuate the soaking tub and marble-framed shower with understated glamour.
Upstairs, the children’s bedroom embraces whimsy with deep blue walls patterned like a night sky. A custom-built bunk bed with brass railing adds both practicality and charm.
A guest bedroom wrapped in turquoise floral wallpaper offers a bright, Parisian-apartment feel, while a fourth bedroom currently functions as a home office, complete with brass-trimmed shelving and terrace access.
2,500 Square Feet of Private Outdoor Living
Perhaps the most compelling feature of the Brooklyn penthouse is its 2,500-square-foot landscaped terrace, envisioned by Gunn Landscape Architecture. Rare for DUMBO, the outdoor space feels more akin to a private rooftop estate than a typical city terrace.
A built-in stainless steel BBQ station anchors one side, while an outdoor dining area beneath a navy canopy extends the entertaining footprint. At the far end, chaise loungers and classical stone accents create a secluded retreat framed by tall hedges and curated plantings.
californialuxuryhouses reached out for additional details regarding the terrace’s irrigation and structural upgrades but did not receive a response prior to publication.
Neighborhood Appeal and Lifestyle Access
DUMBO’s appeal extends beyond architecture. Residents enjoy immediate access to Brooklyn Bridge Park, Empire Stores, and a growing roster of Michelin-recognized dining establishments. The neighborhood provides seamless connectivity to Manhattan via the F train and ferry service, making it attractive to executives and creatives alike.
The penthouse also includes private on-site heated parking—an uncommon amenity in this historic district.
Transaction History and Market Context
Redick and Kilgore acquired the property in 2017 for just over $6 million. Now listed at $6.2 million unfurnished, the pricing reflects both the extensive renovation and Brooklyn’s sustained luxury market resilience.
“The DUMBO luxury market remains selective but strong,” the agent explained to californialuxuryhouses. “Turnkey properties with architectural distinction and outdoor space continue to command attention.”
As Redick’s professional life shifts to Los Angeles, the Brooklyn penthouse stands as a testament to precision—mirroring the discipline that defined his NBA career. From its lacquered Aegean kitchen to its landscaped rooftop sanctuary, the residence blends European elegance with modern New York sensibility.
For a buyer seeking design credibility, privacy, and expansive outdoor living in one of Brooklyn’s most coveted enclaves, this $6.2 million penthouse represents a rare opportunity.