A Landmark Indiana Residence with NFL Legacy
Just over two months after his passing on what would have been his 65th birthday, the lavish Carmel, Indiana estate of longtime Indianapolis Colts owner Jim Irsay is officially on the market. Nestled on more than nine manicured acres beside the renowned Crooked Stick Golf Club, this exceptional property blends opulent amenities with a deep connection to NFL history.
From the 1990s until early 2025, Irsay called this estate home—a retreat designed to balance private serenity with grand-scale entertaining. The listing, represented by Steve Decatur and Jan Sutton of the Decatur Group at Century 21 Scheetz, is attracting immediate interest, with an offer already pending just five days after hitting the market.
Expansive Living Across 25,800 Square Feet
Built in 1996, the estate comprises a two-story main residence plus two standalone guesthouses, offering a combined 25,800 square feet of living space. The property is secured by a gated entrance, a staffed guardhouse, and a fountain-accented motor court, with dedicated garage space for up to eight vehicles.
The main home features six bedrooms, twelve bathrooms, and a series of meticulously crafted living spaces. A formal living room boasts a wood-beamed ceiling, stone fireplace, and French doors that open to a covered terrace. The chandelier-lit dining room is ideal for hosting, while the connected family room and chef’s kitchen—with dark custom cabinetry, an eat-in island, and premium stainless steel appliances—cater to both casual and gourmet dining.
Additional highlights include two primary suites (one on each level), a richly paneled study, nanny’s quarters with a full kitchen, and multiple fireplaces throughout. Recreation spaces abound, from a cinema and gym to a fully outfitted speakeasy.
Indoor and Outdoor Resort-Style Amenities
One of the estate’s most striking features is its indoor basketball court, complete with Colts logos—a nod to Irsay’s decades at the helm of the NFL franchise. There’s also an indoor swimming pool paired with a lounge and backlit bar, plus an additional outdoor pool for warm-weather enjoyment.
Outdoors, residents can enjoy a private par-3 golf hole, tennis court with viewing pavilion, a Zen garden, and two scenic ponds. For younger guests, there’s a bespoke children’s play area, ensuring entertainment for all ages.
Guesthouses for Ultimate Privacy
Two guesthouses provide luxurious accommodations for visitors. “The Cabin,” a newly constructed retreat, offers three bedrooms and four bathrooms, while a charming cottage includes two bedrooms and two bathrooms. Both are thoughtfully designed for comfort and privacy, making them ideal for extended stays or hosting family and friends.
A Rare Opportunity in Carmel Real Estate
With its prime location just north of Indianapolis, proximity to Crooked Stick Golf Club, and unparalleled combination of amenities, this $12 million listing is one of the most prestigious offerings in the Carmel real estate market in recent years. Whether as a full-time residence or a private retreat, it stands as a rare blend of architectural presence, resort-style living, and sports legacy.
