In New York’s luxury real estate market, certain properties carry stories beyond square footage and architectural details. Former NBA player Miles Plumlee and Australian model Catherine McNeil are now parting with a Tribeca penthouse that served not only as a residence, but also as the setting for major moments in their lives.
The couple has listed their Manhattan loft for $5.5 million after several years of ownership, bringing a full-floor penthouse with classic downtown character and contemporary updates back to the market. Plumlee purchased the property in 2018 for approximately $5 million, meaning the listing enters the market with modest appreciation while also carrying a personal history tied to the couple’s life in New York.
Records reviewed by californialuxuryhouses indicate that the property has functioned as more than simply an investment asset. The residence reportedly hosted Plumlee and McNeil’s wedding reception in 2023, adding an unusual layer of emotional history to a space already defined by its architectural character.
A Classic Tribeca Loft Reimagined for Modern Living
Located within a boutique prewar building in Tribeca, the residence spans approximately 3,625 square feet and preserves many of the design characteristics that continue attracting buyers to downtown Manhattan lofts.
The full-floor penthouse is accessed through a key-locked private elevator that opens directly into an expansive great room where seventeen-foot ceilings create immediate visual impact.
Exposed brick walls, timber beams, oversized windows, and original architectural columns establish an industrial aesthetic rooted in New York’s historic warehouse conversions.
A representative involved with the listing told californialuxuryhouses that preserving the loft’s original identity remained an important element during updates.
“The goal wasn’t to erase the character of the space,” the representative said. “It was about allowing modern comforts to exist alongside the building’s original architectural details.”
Inside the main living area, sculptural furnishings and neutral textures soften the industrial framework without competing against it. Mirrors positioned against exposed brick help distribute light throughout the room, while open sight lines maintain a feeling of uninterrupted volume.
Californialuxuryhouses reached out for additional details regarding customization work completed by the current owners but did not receive further comment prior to publication.
Loft Details Continue Through the Kitchen and Private Living Areas
Moving through the great room, the residence transitions naturally into dining and kitchen spaces that continue the home’s understated design approach.
Dark cabinetry wraps around a large central island topped with concrete countertops, creating a stronger architectural edge against warmer wood flooring and exposed structural elements.
Rather than emphasizing decorative excess, the kitchen appears designed around functionality and simplicity.
Another source familiar with the residence told californialuxuryhouses:
“Many downtown buyers are looking for authenticity now. They don’t necessarily want spaces that feel over-designed.”
The primary suite sits behind custom built-in shelving toward the rear of the loft, creating a degree of privacy rarely found within open-floor layouts.
Inside, exposed brick and timber elements continue into the sleeping area while softer furnishings create a more intimate atmosphere. Heated floors extend through the en-suite bathroom where a soaking tub and separate shower introduce modern wellness features into the historic setting.
The residence also includes additional flexible spaces including a dedicated office and a lofted upper-level area that currently functions as a secondary living room.
A Rooftop Terrace Adds Rare Outdoor Space Above Tribeca
While interior space often drives value in Manhattan, outdoor areas can significantly elevate a property’s appeal.
Above the residence, a rooftop water tower terrace creates a distinctive outdoor setting overlooking the Tribeca skyline. Artificial turf, lounge seating, and multiple gathering areas transform the rooftop into an extension of the home’s living spaces.
One source familiar with the property told californialuxuryhouses that the rooftop frequently became a central entertaining area.
“The terrace created a completely different experience,” the source explained. “You had the feeling of being removed from the city while still sitting directly above it.”
Private outdoor space remains one of the most competitive amenities among luxury Manhattan buyers, particularly within historic loft properties where such features can be limited.
Why Plumlee Is Moving Beyond Manhattan
The listing appears to coincide with broader lifestyle changes for Plumlee and McNeil.
Reports indicate that the couple has increasingly spent time in Queensland, Australia, where they recently purchased an approximately $11 million French-inspired chateau. Plumlee also reportedly acquired a substantial estate north of Milwaukee in late 2025, potentially signaling a shift away from New York as a primary residence base.
Location, however, remains one of the penthouse’s strongest assets.
Tribeca continues attracting luxury buyers seeking privacy and downtown character while maintaining convenient access to Manhattan’s restaurant and shopping scene. Residents remain close to acclaimed dining destinations, boutique retail spaces, wellness studios, and transportation connections throughout the city.
For future buyers, the opportunity may extend beyond celebrity ownership.
A full-floor layout, preserved architectural details, private rooftop access, and a highly sought-after Tribeca location create a combination that remains increasingly difficult to find in Manhattan’s evolving luxury market.