Amy Schumer Lists Her Brooklyn Heights Gem
Comedian and actress Amy Schumer has officially placed her 19th-century Brooklyn Heights townhouse on the market for $14 million, marking a significant moment for collectors of historic New York properties and fans of celebrity real estate. Purchased in 2022 for nearly $12.3 million, the townhouse has been meticulously renovated and customized to reflect Schumer’s taste for warmth, elegance, and practicality. The couple, including chef husband Chris Fischer, decided to sell in order to move closer to their son’s school in Manhattan. “He got into a great school, and we’re just too lazy to commute 45 minutes each day,” Schumer revealed to The Wall Street Journal, showcasing the family’s priority for convenience without compromising on lifestyle.
The property is listed with Adam Modlin of Modlin Group alongside Karen and Kyle Talbott of Corcoran Group. According to Modlin, the residence is a rare gem: “This townhouse is a timeless architectural treasure in the heart of Brooklyn Heights,” he told Luxury Houses, emphasizing how it combines historical authenticity with modern luxury.
Historic Significance and Hollywood Connections
Steeped in both architectural and cinematic history, this Amy Schumer Brooklyn house once served as the Castorini family home in the 1987 Oscar-winning film Moonstruck, starring Cher and Nicolas Cage. The Federal-style brick townhouse, characterized by a mansard roof and elegant façades, stretches 26 feet wide and offers over 5,500 square feet across five floors. Its 30 windows flood the interiors with natural light, highlighting original features like fireplaces, millwork, and molding, while contemporary updates harmonize with the historic charm.
The combination of cinematic legacy and residential sophistication enhances the property’s desirability. “Homes like this are more than structures; they are stories,” agent Karen Talbott told Luxury Houses. “Owning this house means owning a piece of both Brooklyn history and Hollywood culture.”
Elegant Interiors Blending History and Modernity
The townhouse’s interior is a perfect marriage of period charm and modern comfort. On the parlor level, dual fireside living rooms are separated by pilaster-framed pocket doors, allowing for flexible entertaining spaces. High ceilings and ornate moldings add grandeur, while French doors lead to an iron-railed terrace that descends to the backyard, creating an effortless indoor-outdoor flow.
The chef’s kitchen, situated on the garden level, features exposed beam ceilings, wide-plank floors, and vintage wood cabinetry. A marble-topped island anchors the space, complemented by top-of-the-line Gaggenau and Lacanche appliances. An adjacent butler’s pantry and breakfast nook provide practicality, while a converted library with rich wood paneling adds a cozy, refined touch. The landscape architect Michael Van Valkenburgh transformed the backyard from a brick patio into a private turf-clad play area, providing both recreation and the option for a gated parking space—a rare feature in Brooklyn Heights.
Primary Suite Retreat and Upper-Level Bedrooms
The entire third floor is dedicated to a luxurious primary suite, offering a corner bedroom warmed by a working fireplace, a dressing room, a private office, and a marble bath with a clawfoot soaking tub, dual vanities, and a glass-encased shower. “It’s a sanctuary that perfectly balances elegance and everyday comfort,” says agent Kyle Talbott. Every detail, from the original floors to the modern fixtures, reflects Schumer’s thoughtful approach to blending history with contemporary needs.
Three additional bedrooms occupy the top floor, sharing a beautifully restored penny-tiled bath. A Miele washer and dryer is conveniently located on this level, enhancing functionality without disrupting the classic aesthetic. The thoughtful layout makes the Amy Schumer Brooklyn house ideal for families seeking both space and style in an iconic neighborhood.
Lower Level for Lifestyle and Leisure
The townhouse’s finished basement provides an exceptional combination of leisure and utility. It houses a custom wine cellar, a fully equipped home gym, and a secondary laundry area. These modern amenities coexist seamlessly with the historic architecture above, offering a lifestyle that satisfies both practical needs and luxury aspirations.
Schumer’s attention to detail and personal touch is evident throughout, from carefully selected lighting to restored period hardware. Every room tells a story of living history, making the residence both charming and highly functional.
Brooklyn Heights: Historic Elegance Meets Urban Convenience
Nestled in the prestigious Brooklyn Heights, the home benefits from the neighborhood’s cobblestone streets, tree-lined avenues, and breathtaking views of the Manhattan skyline. Residents enjoy proximity to cultural landmarks, Michelin-starred restaurants, top-tier private schools, and the famous Brooklyn Promenade. The area effortlessly combines quiet residential charm with easy access to New York City’s urban heartbeat.
“Brooklyn Heights is a neighborhood that represents both legacy and lifestyle,” shares Adam Modlin. “This townhouse embodies the very spirit of the area—elegant, inviting, and historically significant.”
A Rare Opportunity for Luxury Buyers
For prospective buyers, this Amy Schumer Brooklyn house offers more than luxury—it offers legacy. The combination of historic architecture, cinematic connections, modern renovations, and a prime Brooklyn Heights location makes it a one-of-a-kind opportunity in New York City real estate.
The home’s story, refined design, and thoughtful updates create a narrative that resonates with both history enthusiasts and modern families. Schumer’s personal taste, blended with the timeless appeal of the townhouse, ensures that the residence remains not just a house, but a living landmark with enduring charm.